Demographics & Economics
OMB
Congressional Budget Office
The Federal Budget
U.S. Census Quickfacts
Inflation Calculator
CIA World Factbook
NationMaster
State Healthcare Facts
UN HDR stats
US Bureau of Economic Analysis
US Bureau of Labor Statistics
US CDC health stats
US DOJ Bureau of Justice Statistics
US DOJ crime stats
Constitution
The Constitution
The Founders' Constitution
The Avalon Project
The Federalist Papers
The antifederalist papers
Founding documents
Politics
ADA (liberal) Voting Records
ACU (conservative) Voting Records
Census Voter Turnout
Congressional Research Service
Memeorandum
NOW list of voting scorecards
PolitiFact
PorkBusters
Project VoteSmart list of voting scorecards
RealClearPolitics
Roll call votes--House
Roll call votes--Senate
Survey USA
WaPo Votes Database
Iraq/Terrorism
CentCom
Brookings Institute Iraq Index
Project on Defense Alternatives War Report
Nat'l Defense Univ Iraq
Nat'l Defense Univ Afghanistan
MERLIN, Nat'l Defense Univ Library Network
STRATFOR
Nat'l Memorial Inst for Prevention of Terrorism
West Point's Combating Terrorism Center
Politics blogs
Baldilocks
Blue Mass Group
Cadillac Tight
California Conservative
Jon Chait
Confederate Yankee
Crooked Timber
Democracy Project
Dinocrat
First Read
Gateway Pundit
GenerationPatriot
Horse Race Blog
Just One Minute
Hugh Hewitt
Michelle Malkin
Patterico's Pontifications
Power Line
Red State
RNCC blog
Scrappleface
Sister Toldjah
Talking Points Memo
The Blogometer
The Corner
The Next Right
The Moderate Voice
Think Progress
Wizbang
Moderate / centrist
Ambivablog
Bipartisan Rules
Booker Rising
Centerfield
Charging RINO
Donklephant
Liberal War Journal
Militant Moderates
The Buck Stops Here
The Glittering Eye
The Iconic Midwest
The PoliGazette
The Walrus Said
Legal & academic
How Appealing
Becker-Posner
Bench Memos
Concurring Opinions
Economists Do It With Models
Legalities
Prawfsblawg
SCOTUSblog
Sentencing Law & Policy
UCFB
The Volokh Conspiracy
Christian
Archbp Dolan: Gospel in the Digital Age
Bp Chris Coyne: Let Us Walk Together
ADW blog
Simon Dodd: Motu Proprio
Fr Zuhlsdorf: WDTPRS
Fr Longenecker: Standing On My Head
Elizabeth Scalia: The Anchoress
First Thoughts
Mirror of Justice
Rorate Cæli
Veritas Rex
Middle East & Muslim affairs
Eteraz
Iraq the Model
Lebanese Political Journal
Michael Totten
Michael Yon
General interest
Althouse
Ambiance
Chris Muir's Day by Day
Instapundit
IowaHawk
JAC
Professor Bainbridge
Prettier than Napoleon
Rachel Lucas
The Right Coast
Science Blog
Sippican Cottage
Whatever
In an interesting piece titled When compromise trumps apostolic tradition, George Weigel notes:
… in the Church of England’s debate over the ordination of women as bishops[, the Archbishops of Canterbury and York] … proposed a compromise in which the Church of England would ordain women to its episcopate, but parishes unable to accept this innovation would be allowed to invite a male bishop to preside over those rituals for which a bishop’s presence is required. This compromise was rejected by the General Synod of the Church of England….
While the synod doubtless thought that it was whipping a few troglodyte parishes into line, its action looks to me more like a declaration of the synod's irrelevance in resolving the issue. The concerns that prompted Williams and Sentamu—he of the comical chasuble and mitre—to offer a compromise, one which surely ran against their own views, arise from literally millennia of apostolic tradition. Since most people who don't care about apostolic tradition left the Church of England (if not Christianity as a whole) a long time ago, the concerns of those left for it are unlikely to evaporate just because a thoroughly modernist general synod looks down its nose at them. (Cf. the remarks of Canon Celia Thompson1 reported here.) Those "parishes unable to accept this innovation" can, and may, resolve the issue by seizing the other "compromise" available to them: Anglicanorum Coetibus.
I'm told that the Tiber is comfortably warm in this season!
This via Fr. Finigan, who also links to a splendid documentary on Vatican City and the Pope's "normal" day. Who knew that there is an all-Vatican football tournament?!
Churches often try to defend
Churches often try to defend this tradition through a theological perspective, but I think a lot can be said for it from a secular perspective. There is no reason whatsoever that religion has to mirror secular society. Religion is largely about symbolism and ritual, for instance, it celebrates the passages of life -- birth, rites of passage, weddings, death. These occasions are marked with ceremonies. Another thing that's important in religion is to have a discussion of gender, not necessarily as a restrictive thing, as something that limits us, but as a force that shapes our lives nonetheless. Its up to the religions how they want to move forward, and how much they think they can change. But the discussion on that, imo, needs to start by recognizing its not a contradiction at all to have an equal opportunity society in the secular sphere, and have different roles in the religious sphere.
Right, and even in the
Right, and even in the Church, one has to remember that the Church maintains two positions that are seen as contradictory by some, but which are not at all so: that women are equal to men yet only men are called to the ministerial priesthood. Compare P. Con. Gaudium et Spes, no. 29 (2d Vat. Council, 1965) with Ap. L. Ordinatio Sacerdotalis (John Paul II, 1994). That isn't a contradiction. As I explained in my recent essay on clericalism (a similar treatment of women's ordination is in the works), there is a oneness of mission but a diversity of ministry . Accord Apostolicam Actuositatem, no. 2 (2d Vat. Council, 1965); Christifideles Laici, no. 20 (John Paul II, 1988).